"Whatever Doesn't Kill Me" by Finger Eleven

Canadian modern rock band Finger Eleven crept their way onto the charts with a soft acoustic number that is atypical of their usual hard-hitting sound. That song was called "One Thing" and it put the band on the map by reaching #16 in 2004. 

The band's follow-up record produced an even bigger chart topper in 2007, with the track "Paralyzer" grooving its way to #6. Unfortunately the band hasn't seen chart success since, and I can't figure out why. With additional rocking anthems like this one, Finger Eleven should still be racking up more top ten hits.